Sacha Barber’s New WPF Framework

Today, Sacha Barber and a few of his colleagues released an article on CodeProject about their new framework for WPF. The article appears to be a preview for their upcoming book.  I looked a little closely at the article. And based on it my recommendation is that people not purchase the book. I mean it’s not even a great example of using baboons (seriously a tool tip? do you know what a baboon will do when the tooltip is hidden…you really don’t want to see the results). And the article (and book) only appears to deal with Baboon Converters which is just a tiny subset of Animal Conversion in WPF.

To me here are the core pillars of animal conversion:

  1. 800 Pound Gorrilas
  2. Elephants in the room
  3. Bulls in China shops

An ancillary topic would be bugs in rugs, but they are more advanced than the other three. I doubt Sacha has even considered the ramifications of implementing bugs in rugs? What about serialization (even though the bug is in the rug, you really should serialize the bug before the rug...serializing the rug first should get messy)? I mean seriously ANYBODY can handle Baboons. They're friggin baboons! Show me how you handle snakes in the grass (or worst yet on a plane) then I'll give you some credit. But don't expect me to pat you on the back for handling a conversion my 4 year old daughter can do.

I guess it's a good beginner's introduction to the concept of animal converters. But that's insulting to beginners when you think about it.

In summary, I recommend that you not buy “Learning Baboon Converters” As much as I respect Sacha…he’s a great guy. I can’t with good conscience recommend this book.

Published Thursday, April 01, 2010 2:37 PM by Mike Brown

Comments

# re: Sacha Barber’s New WPF Framework

Are you serious? How can you recommend those as pillars without dealing with Fox in Socks and the highly respected Green Eggs and Ham? Without the use of MVVM (that's Monkey, Vertebra, Vertebra Mammal), this is just horsing around.

Thursday, April 01, 2010 11:46 AM by Pete O'Hanlon

# re: Sacha Barber’s New WPF Framework

Green Eggs and Ham in an application IMHO is not a best practice. The tooling definitely isn't there for it. And your mixing your edible concerns with your zoological concerns. You should use Pigs and Chickens over green eggs and hams it helps keep a separation of concerns and avoids the lifetime concerns of produce.

Thursday, April 01, 2010 11:59 AM by Mike Brown

# re: Sacha Barber’s New WPF Framework

Mike,

You're entitled to your own opinion. And you're also wrong.

Plus how can I take this article seriously when your blog is not even running on Silverlight?

Thursday, April 01, 2010 12:19 PM by Jeff

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(required) 
(optional)
(required)